Russia-Ukraine war live: Zelenskiy aide blames Russia for blowing up dam; White House ‘assessing’ if attack is war crime | Russia

Exclusive: Zelenskiy chief of staff says he ‘does not understand’ how there are any doubts Russian forces blew up Nova Kakhovka dam

Dan Sabbagh

Dan Sabbagh

Andriy Yermak, Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s chief of staff, said he “did not understand” how there could be any doubt about whether Russian forces blew up the Nova Kakhovka dam. In a statement given to the Guardian, the senior aide said the dam could not have been destroyed through shelling or “any other external influence” – while another adviser to the president said the attack amounted to a war crime.

In the statement, Andriy Yermak, head of the Ukrainian presidential administration, said: “At 2:50am this morning, Russian troops blew up the Kakhovka hydroelectric Station and its dam. I do not understand how there can be any doubt about this. Both constructions are located in the temporary Russian-occupied territories. Neither shelling nor any other external influence was capable of destroying the structures. The explosion came from within.

“We know that Russian troops had mined the hydroelectric Station in the early days of the full-scale invasion, so the pre-meditated blast is the only plausible explanation. Any alternative theories are nothing less than false Russian propaganda narratives.”

Dasha Zarivna, a senior adviser in the Ukrainian presidential office, who was born and raised in Kherson, said: “The dam bombing is another unprecedented Russian war crime against Ukraine, which will have catastrophic consequences both for its population and other countries. These include environmental and economic consequences, a great risk from radiation and further serious disruption to food security.

“Last October, President Zelenskiy said: ‘All the world leaders should let Russia understand that a terrorist attack on the Kakhovka hydroelectric station will be equated to the use of weapons of mass destruction’. Now it has happened. World leaders must recognise the equivalence, and now must act decisively. It is essential to isolate the terrorist state as completely as possible. Any economic ties with Russia outside of humanitarian activities should be regarded as complicity in its war crimes.”

Key events

Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov is warning, again, of an “escalation” in the war in Ukraine if western allies provide F-16 fighter jets for use in the conflict.

“We must keep in mind that one of the modifications of the F-16 can ‘accommodate’ nuclear weapons,” he said Tuesday in a speech at a military base in Dushanbe, Tajikistan, according to Reuters.

Lavrov said U.S.-built F-16 fighter jets can ‘accommodate’ nuclear weapons and warned that supplying Kyiv with them will escalate the conflict further. https://t.co/t0eddbotvf.

— John Hudson (@John_Hudson) June 6, 2023

“If they do not understand this, then they are worthless as military strategists and planners.”

A number of nations, including the UK, have said in recent weeks that they want to help procure the fighter jets for Ukraine. Joe Biden has not committed to supplying aircraft, but has said the US will back an international effort to train Ukrainian pilots to fly them before doing so.

John Kirby, White House coordinator of strategic communications for the National Security Council, spoke to reporters about F-16s on Tuesday:

The purpose of providing advanced fighter aircraft is to help Ukraine defend itself defend its airspace and its territorial integrity, period.

To Lavrov, he added:

If you’re worried about Ukrainian military capabilities, then you should take your troops and leave Ukraine.

Read more:

Interim summary

Here’s where things stand on a day in the Ukraine war dominated by news of the collapse of the Nova Kakhovka dam following an explosion:

  • Ukraine president Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s chief of staff says he ‘does not understand’ how there are any doubts that Russian forces blew up the dam. In a statement, Andriy Yermak said: “At 2.50am, Russian troops blew up the Kakhovka hydroelectric station and its dam. I do not understand how there can be any doubt about this. Both constructions are located in the temporary Russian-occupied territories. Neither shelling nor any other external influence was capable of destroying the structures. The explosion came from within.”

  • The Kremlin accuses Ukraine of deliberately sabotaging the dam. Dmitry Peskov, the Kremlin’s spokesperson, told reporters: “We can state unequivocally that we are talking about deliberate sabotage by the Ukrainian side.” He said [Russian president] Vladimir Putin had been briefed on the situation.

  • The US “cannot say conclusively” who was responsible. National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby told reporters at the White House: “We’re doing the best we can to assess”, noting “destruction of civilian infrastructure is not allowed by the laws of war”. Earlier Tuesday, NBC News reported that the US government had intelligence indicating Russia was behind the incident, according to two US officials and one western official.

  • The Ukrainian government called for people living downstream to evacuate in the face of catastrophic flooding. Energy company Ukrahydroenergo said the hydroelectric power plant at the dam had been blown up from the inside and was irreparable.

  • The governor of the Kherson region, Oleksandr Prokudin, said about 16,000 people were in the “critical zone” on the Ukrainian-controlled right bank of the river.

  • The areas most under threat of flooding are the islands along the course of the Dnipro downstream of Nova Kakhovka and much of the Russian-held left bank in southern Kherson. Andrey Alekseyenko, one of the Russian-installed officials in occupied Kherson, has posted to Telegram to say that up to 22,000 people are in the flood plains in Russian-controlled territory.

  • Ukraine’s foreign ministry called for an urgent meeting of UN security council to discuss what it called a Russian “terrorist act against Ukrainian critical infrastructure”.

  • There seems to be no immediate safety threat to the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant from the collapse of the Nova Kakhovka dam 200km downstream, according to Ukrainian and UN experts. Water from the reservoir affected by the destruction of the dam is used to supply the plant’s cooling systems.

  • The British foreign secretary, James Cleverly, who is in Ukraine, blamed the destruction on Russia’s invasion. “I’ve heard reports of the explosion on the dam and the risk of flooding. It’s too early to make any kind of meaningful assessment of the details,” he said.

Here’s what you need to know about the dam:

White House ‘assessing’ if dam attack is war crime

John Kirby, coordinator for strategic communications at the National Security Council, has just spoken at the White House, and says the US is “assessing” the attack on the Nova Kakhovk dam.

He was asked if the Biden administration considers it a war crime:

I don’t have a determination on that to speak to today. I would just say we’re still trying to assess what happened here, but the Russians had illegally taken over that dam in the reservoir many months ago, and they were occupying it when this explosion happened.

It’s very clear that the deliberate destruction of civilian infrastructure is not allowed by the laws of war, and in the additional protocol to the Geneva Convention that the Russians have themselves signed, destruction of civilian infrastructure, such as dams, are clearly articulated in their violations of that code.

But again, we haven’t made a decision. We’re still talking to the Ukrainians.

National Security Council Coordinator for strategic communications John Kirby briefs reporters at the White House about the attack on the Nova Kakhovk dam: “[We] cannot say conclusively what happened at this point” but adds that the US expects many deaths from the explosion.
National Security Council coordinator for strategic communications, John Kirby, briefs reporters at the White House about the attack on the Nova Kakhovk dam: “[We] cannot say conclusively what happened at this point” but adds that the US expects many deaths from the explosion. Photograph: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP/Getty Images

Kirby is also promising that more support for Ukraine will be coming in short order as a potential “repercussion” of the attack:

I guarantee you, you’re gonna see additional security assistance packages in coming days and weeks. We’re going to continue to make sure that Ukraine can succeed on the battlefield, as President Biden has said.

If Russia is concerned about Ukrainian military capabilities, best thing that they can do would be to leave Ukraine.

We have made our concerns about strikes inside Russia very clear to Ukrainian officials. They’ve acknowledged that and they have assured us that they won’t use US-made equipment to strike inside Russia.

We don’t want to see the war escalate and, and there’s no apologies for that. But I won’t go into detail about the private discussions that we’re having with with Ukrainians.

Reuters reports that Russia’s foreign ministry said it summoned Belgium’s ambassador on Tuesday to protest what it said was the use of “Belgian weapons” by pro-Ukraine militants that attacked Russian territory last month.

This claim has not been independently verified.

The Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, has said “35 to 70 towns will be flooded” along the Dnipro River after the blowing up of Nova Kakhovka dam.

He also said there could be problems accessing clean drinking water while speaking at a briefing on Tuesday.

“There will be big problems with drinking water even where there is no flooding. In the whole region,” he said.

Earlier on Tuesday, Andrei Alexeyenko, chairman of the Russian-appointed government of Ukraine’s Kherson province, said the small town of Oleshky, which lies on the southern bank of the Dnipro River, was almost completely flooded.

On Telegram, Alexeyenko posted videos showing one car standing in flood water up to the window and a lorry driving along a highway in water at least a foot deep.

Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the EU commission, said on Twitter that Russia would have to “pay for the war crimes committed in Ukraine”.

She called the destruction of Nova Kakhovka dam an “outrageous attack on civilian infrastructure [that] puts at risk thousands of people in the Kherson region.”

She also confirmed that the EU has engaged its civil protection mechanism, which would “rapidly deliver” dirt water pumps, fire hoses, mobile water purification stations and boats to those affected by the dam explosion.

Russia will have to pay for the war crimes committed in Ukraine.

The destruction of the dam, an outrageous attack on civilian infrastructure, puts at risk thousands of people in the Kherson region.

Europe is mobilising support through our civil protection mechanism.

— Ursula von der Leyen (@vonderleyen) June 6, 2023

NBC News reports that the US government has intelligence that indicates Russia is behind the blowing up of the Nova Kakhovka dam, according to two US officials and one western official.

President Joe Biden’s administration was working to declassify some of the intelligence and share it as early as Tuesday afternoon.

The western official said the collapse appears likely to make it more difficult for Ukrainian forces to conduct a river crossing.

Julian Borger, our world affairs editor, writes about the long-term impacts of the Nova Kakhovka dam collapse

The people living along Ukraine’s lower Dnipro river must contend with the immediate consequences of the collapse of the Nova Kakhovka dam and flee for safety with whatever they can salvage, but the wider impact could make itself felt for generations.

Downstream, the flood waters will subside somewhat as the surge reaches the Black Sea, but many of the villages and towns along the course of the Dnipro may not be habitable again unless and until a new dam is built. Thousands of homes and livelihoods have been swept away, along with countless domesticated and wild animals.

The ecological trauma of such an inundation of water and silt has changed the landscape in an instant, wiping away islands and wetlands. It could take years if not decades for the fauna and flora to bounce back. Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, called it the “largest human-made environmental disaster in Europe in decades”. It is the country’s misfortune to have also been the site of the Chornobyl disaster in 1986, arguably the last calamity on such a scale.

Read more: Devastation from Kakhovka dam collapse could take decades to heal

Exclusive: Zelenskiy chief of staff says he ‘does not understand’ how there are any doubts Russian forces blew up Nova Kakhovka dam

Dan Sabbagh

Dan Sabbagh

Andriy Yermak, Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s chief of staff, said he “did not understand” how there could be any doubt about whether Russian forces blew up the Nova Kakhovka dam. In a statement given to the Guardian, the senior aide said the dam could not have been destroyed through shelling or “any other external influence” – while another adviser to the president said the attack amounted to a war crime.

In the statement, Andriy Yermak, head of the Ukrainian presidential administration, said: “At 2:50am this morning, Russian troops blew up the Kakhovka hydroelectric Station and its dam. I do not understand how there can be any doubt about this. Both constructions are located in the temporary Russian-occupied territories. Neither shelling nor any other external influence was capable of destroying the structures. The explosion came from within.

“We know that Russian troops had mined the hydroelectric Station in the early days of the full-scale invasion, so the pre-meditated blast is the only plausible explanation. Any alternative theories are nothing less than false Russian propaganda narratives.”

Dasha Zarivna, a senior adviser in the Ukrainian presidential office, who was born and raised in Kherson, said: “The dam bombing is another unprecedented Russian war crime against Ukraine, which will have catastrophic consequences both for its population and other countries. These include environmental and economic consequences, a great risk from radiation and further serious disruption to food security.

“Last October, President Zelenskiy said: ‘All the world leaders should let Russia understand that a terrorist attack on the Kakhovka hydroelectric station will be equated to the use of weapons of mass destruction’. Now it has happened. World leaders must recognise the equivalence, and now must act decisively. It is essential to isolate the terrorist state as completely as possible. Any economic ties with Russia outside of humanitarian activities should be regarded as complicity in its war crimes.”

The UN secretary-general, António Guterres, calls the blowing up of Nova Kakhovka dam a consequence of the Russian invasion, Reuters reports.

Speaking to reporters, Guterres said “one thing is clear, this is another devastating consequence of the Russian invasion of Ukraine.”

“Attacks against civilians and critical civilian infrastructure must stop. We must act to ensure accountability and respect for international humanitarian law,” he continued.

Guterres added that it was a “monumental humanitarian, economic and ecological catastrophe.”

“At least 16,000 people have already lost their homes – with safe and clean drinking water supplies at risk for many thousands more,” he said.

He added that the UN was coordinating with the Ukrainian government to send support including drinking water and water purification tablets.

Ukraine and Russia have both asked the UN security council to meet to discuss the incident.

Here are some images of nearby residents wading through flood water after the Nova Kakhovka dam explosion.

A local resident makes her way through a flooded road.
A local resident makes her way through a flooded road. Photograph: Evgeniy Maloletka/AP
A local resident, Tetiana, holds her pets, Tsatsa and Chunya, as she stands inside her house that was flooded.
A local resident, Tetiana, holds her pets, Tsatsa and Chunya, as she stands inside her house that was flooded. Photograph: Evgeniy Maloletka/AP
Local residents try to ride their bikes along a flooded road.
Local residents try to ride their bikes along a flooded road. Photograph: Evgeniy Maloletka/AP



Source link